I didn't mention that I created the shape of this part by combining a larger outside ring feature shape with a smaller inside "remove material" feature shape. So this part is really a combination of 1 add material and 1 remove material shapes. If I change that other part to "remove material" then both of the features are now remove, so nothing is shown and the part no longer has a shape.
Maybe there is no way to have a custom Part like this that removes material? I guess I could make a new part with "remove material" only with a sketch?